Now, I've had all night to calm down about this.
Harry Potter is a good film. They're all better actors now, Jim Broadbent and Tom Felton are great, the special effects are good, it's funny, it's sad, and yes, I mainly enjoyed it.
Except for the fact that they miss out most of the book. It would always be expected that a large amount would have to be left out, it is a mahoosive book and what they DID keep in still filled over two hours, which is long enough. You can understand them missing out bits that don't really matter, like random lessons, lounging about in the common room, blah blah blah. But when the film ended, there was this feeling of "...Er, no! Where's the rest of it?". They missed out really, really important bits. Like, main plotlines. Not good.
So when I got home, I dug out the book and had a scan through it.
I don't want to give too much away (but I've a feeling I'm about to anyway). The writers, with their apparent superior wisdom to JK Rowling's original ideas, miss out (in no particular order, as they occur to me):
- Fleur and Bill getting engaged. They're not even in it.
- Tonks having feelings for Lupin.
- Harry telling Ron and Herminone about the prophecy.
- Getting their OWL results - this is a SCHOOL they go to, after all.
- Harry learning about the Gaunt family in the Pensieve.
- Lupin telling everyone about Fenrir being a werewolf - Fenrir is in the film, but you don't see much of him, he's just an ugly looking bloke.
- Hermione researches who the Half Blood Prince could be and tells them all about former student Eileen Prince, who it could well be.
- They didn't really explain what Horcruxes are properly or where they are (although I did go for a wee at this point), which is kind of important for number 7, which is about destroying the Horcruxes.
- When Harry uses Sectusempra against Draco Malfoy (who, by the way, is dressed in a dark suit like a Bond villain throughout the entire thing), Snape reads Harry's mind and learns Harry has the old spell book which belonged to the H-B P. He demands he hands it over, so Harry gives him Ron's copy instead and hides the book in the room of requirement. (In the film, Ginny suggests he hides it, takes him there, and snogs him.)
- Prof. Trewlawney tells Harry about the Death Eaters getting into the school through the Room of Requirement.
- BIG ONE! Harry tells Ron and Herminone to reform Dumbledore's Army while he and Dumbledore go to the cave to get the Horcrux (they do go to the cave and it is a good scene - phew).
- Snape and Harry have a duel with Harry using some of the Half Blood Prince's spells against him, which is when Snape is supposed to reveal that he was the H-B P. But seeing as they've pretty much ignored this whole storyline, it's a bit weird when Alan Rickman booms "Yes...I am the Half Blood Prince!". So? No one's cared up until now. (Maybe if you'd let Hermione look into it...)
- In the astronomy tower, Dumbledore is supposed to Petrify Harry while he's under the invisibility cloak so that he doesn't get hurt or interfere. He doesn't. (This really annoyed me because in his visible and non-Petrified state, Harry WOULD'VE interfered, not just hidden! He never hides! He has to be the hero, that's the POINT!)
- There is supposed to be a battle between the school and the Death Eaters! A BIG BATTLE! Bill is supposed to get horribly disfigured by Fenrir but Fleur doesn't mind, she loves him anyway, yadda yadda. But like I said in the first line...
- Hermione does more research and finds out that Eileen Prince was Snape's mother. His dad was a muggle. Hence why he was called Half-Blood Prince. So, pretty important we know that, yes?
BIGGEST GRIPE:
- There's no funeral for Dumbledore. No big white tomb, everyone distraught, not knowing if Hogwarts will reopen. No. It ends with them looking at some scenery.
Anything else?
Oh yes. All the stuff they added that wasn't in the book, like Bellatrix arriving at The Burrow and running off into the corn field, with Harry chasing her, which meant Ginny chased Harry, which meant Mr Weasley chased her, which meant Lupin chased him, before Bella flew back to the house and set fire to it while they all stood watching it burn. It added nothing to the film in terms of plot or direction, and, if they HADN'T added it, it would've meant there was time for the rest of it to be put in. LIKE THE BATTLE AND THE FUNERAL. THE MAIN PARTS.
There's artistic license and there's taking the piss. I would've rather they had split the film into two parts like they plan to for film 7.
Hmph.
Still good though.